Home > Sports > Football (American) > Are eli manning, phillip rivers, or ben roethllisburger hall of fame caliber quarterbacks?

Are eli manning, phillip rivers, or ben roethllisburger hall of fame caliber quarterbacks?

if you ask me I believe that in order to make the hall of fame you must be compared to the greats who came before and longevity shouldnt play such a huge factor.take earl campbell … earl campbell played for only 8 years out of those 8 years u can take 5 of his years and compare them to any 5 years of walter payton, barry sanders, emit smith, jim brown, ect career. but can u compare 5 years of big ben, phillip rivers, or eli years in the nfl to tom brady, payton manning, joe montana, john Elway, dan marino, brett favre, drew brees, ect?
  • Answers
  • Eli,, Ben.
    Michael Palumbo · 1 0
  • Big Ben yes. Phillip rivers is a Stat QB so a solid maybe. Eli has be very inconsistent. I dont think he deserves it.
    Logan · 0 0
  • Manning did it in the playoffs and took down the heavily favored Patriots in the Superbowl 2 times.
    michael · 0 0
  • Tom Brady
    Ronnie · 0 2
  • Eli Manning will probably be put in, I don't think he deserves to be but yeah he's playing in NY and has two Super Bowls AND beat the Media darling Brady and Patriots both times.

    Rivers has the numbers to say he will eventually get in. To those who would say well he has no rings, yeah neither did Marino. I admit that Rivers isn't seen in quite that same light, but saying it defends putting him in still.

    Big Ben has the career that says he belongs in the hall. I realize most don't look at his actual numbers and notice it but honestly look at them sometime.
    Goldfly252000 · 1 2
Amazon Ads